|
PASSING ON THE FAITH (CATECHESIS) IN ANCIENT TIMES
Reflections on the History of the Sacraments as revealed
through the palaeochristian evidence.
This article, written by Alessandro
Bertolino, a young student of archaeology and guide at the Catacombs
of San Callisto, present us with the long journey of formation undertaken
by future Christians. From the inscribing of this names in the lists
of catechumens, through the various phases of religious instruction
until their admission into the community of the Church. The teaching
methods followed are described together with the rites of preparation
and conferring of the Sacrament of Baptism. Evidence of this comes from
the archaeological data of the baptisteries and the sepulchral inscriptions.
The work is enriched by a select bibliography.
1. The Catechumenate
The institution of a preliminary phase which consisted
in an adequate period of preparation for Baptism had already been developed
by the end of the second century. A prebaptismal catechesis was developed
for this. It was well-suited to form those who aspired to become Christians
and who in this time of preparation came to be called catechumens (those
who were under instruction).
The Catechumenate (1) proper began at the moment when
the candidates presented themselves to the catechists and had their
names inscribed in the lists kept by the deacons. This act of Enrolment
envisaged that the aspirants be accompanied by some of the believers
who were to testify to their right intentions and true commitment in
the knowledge of the Christian faith. Thus the candidates' first steps
were not taken alone but in full sight of the community thanks to the
presence of witnesses who much later came to be called "godparents".
St. Augustine (2) informs us of this practice and clearly explains their
function.
"To have better assurance of the dispositions of the candidates,
it is most useful to be informed by the inquiries of the friends of
the catechumens on their interior dispositions and what urges them
towards religion."
Thus the office of godparent is attested to as existing
in the organisation underlining the community dimension of the journey
the catechumen was about to undertake. After the Enrolment of names
and Presentation of the Candidates, they went on to examine their lives,
the occupations they followed and the motives which animated them. The
questioning, often rigorous, was intended to assure the Church that
the practical conditions existed for actually living the Christian life,
uncompromised by pagan customs and immorality. A detailed list of activities
incompatible with being a Christian is furnished by a Third Century
text called the Apostolic Tradition (3).
The trades and occupations of those being brought for instruction
must be examined. If they run brothels, they must give them up or
be sent away. If they are sculptors or painters they be told not to
make representations of idols; they must give this up or be sent away.
If they are actors, they must give this up or be sent away. If they
are racing charioteers or participate in the public games, they must
give this up or be sent away. If they are gladiators or train gladiators
to fight, or are officials involved in arranging gladiatorial games,
they must give this up or be sent away. Prostitutes, lechers, the
dissolute and others we cannot speak well of, must be sent away because
they are impure. Magicians must not be taken before the examiner.
Forgers, astrologers, diviners, interpreters of dreams, charlatans,
liers, makers of amulets, they must give these up or be sent away.
He who has a concubine must give her up and take a wife according
to the law; if he won't he must be sent away. As can be seen the practice
of certain professions, which were in some way connected with pagan
religion impeded people from receiving Baptism. The intransigence which
is apparent in the sources is explained by the expressed desire of the
early Christian community to cut themselves off completely from the
surrounding pagan customs. Catechumens, if they passed the examination,
even before receiving the Sacrament, were considered members of the
church community. The time of catechetical instruction effected the
progressive integration into the Church and culminated in Baptism.
The period of preparation which followed (Enrolment) generally lasted
three years; the length of the catechumenate could also be shortened
in exceptional cases where there was praiseworthy application and zeal
in the catechumen. It was during this time that the catechumens, in
designated places, came to be adequately instructed in Christian Doctrine.
The catechists appointed to this task, might be deacons or presbyters
but the better educated laity were certainly not excluded. An example
of this was Origen who, accountable to the Bishop of Alexandria, ran
a true and proper university of theology and biblical exegesis. During
their years of formation, catechumens could take part in the weekly
liturgical gathering, even if there were some fundamental limitations.
There were places reserved for them separate from the faithful. They
took part only in the Liturgy of the Word and were allowed to listen
to the homily. After this they were sent out and had to await the end
of the Mass in a part separated from the Church building:the narthex
which was a rectangular place at right angles to the main axis of the
church and against the facade.
When the period of preparation was over, there followed an intensive
period of living the faith, Lent, which preceded Baptism which was foreseen
as taking place on the night of Easter. They were examined a second
time to verify their application during the period of formation and
hence their names were inscribed by the Bishop himself in the "Book
of the Church". By this action, the catechumen became Elect, chosen
to be inscribed among the citizens of the Heavenly Jerusalem. At this
point the whole of Lent was lived by the catechumens taking part in
meetings, almost daily instruction, vigils of prayer and fasting for
purification. St. John Chrysostom (4), Bishop of Antioch in the IVth
century, addressing the Elect of his diocese concludes in highly lyrical
terms, one of these prebaptismal gatherings:
"You are already fragrant with happiness, O chosen ones (Elect).
You are already gathering the mystical blossoms to weave into heavenly
crowns. We are living in a time of joy and happiness! Behold, in fact,
the objects of our love and desires, the days of our spiritual wedding
have arrived."
In the context of Lenten preparation, there were some rites full of
symbolic meaning. Among these was the Exorcism which consisted in prayers
while breathing on the face of the candidate and in marking their foreheads.
Thus is was shown that the person had been snatched from the power of
evil and bound ever more to Christ. The Handing over of the Symbol containing
the main beliefs of Christianity assumed a particular sstress. These
were explained so that they could be accepted by the catechumens, who
would have to recite them solemnly before the Bishop on Palm Sunday
in the Ceremony of the Handing Back of the Symbol. The whole preparation
was brought to a conclusion with the final rite of Renunciation to Satan
and joining with Christ which was done on Holy Thursday or on the Paschal
Night itself. Facing the West, where the Powers of Darkness dwelt, the
catechumens renounced their earlier condition of slavery to sin. Then
turning to the East, site of Paradise and the place where the Light
of Christ arose, the catechumen made a solemn profession of faith in
the Blessed Trinity.
2. Catechetical Method (Method of Teaching)
As we have already underlined, instruction in the faith was confided
to the clergy or to well-formed laity. Fortunately, the manuscript tradition
has preserved some of these teachings directed to the catechumens or
neophytes by the most cultured spirits of the epoch. Among these we
must remember the "Mystagogical Catechesis" of Cyril of Jerusalem, the
"De Mysteriis" of Ambrose and in particular the "De Catachizandis Rudibus"of
Augustine. This last was a veritable treatise on teaching (catechetical)
method, still extremely valuable today in giving us points to be usefully
reflected upon. It was written to satisfy the request of a Carthaginian
deacon, Deogratias, unhappy because he was convinced that he was boring
his hearers instead of enlightening them in the faith (5).
"You have asked me, Brother Deogratias, to write you something
useful on the method of teaching the faith. You have had difficulty
in finding a method adapted to teaching doctrine . . . You tell me
that during the long and tiresome meetings you hold, you regret that
for a long time you have felt embarrassed and even disgusted with
yourself being therefore very far from instructing your audience and
those who come to listen to you."
Augustine then develops a series of teaching principles concerning
catechesis (handing on the faith) so that it always be done in a spirit
of joy, hilaritas, seeking to find the best conditions for adapting
to the abilities of the hearers. He proceeds to examine all the possible
situations in which catechists might find themselves and provides solutions
to the various problems and obstacles the catechumens provide. The African
bishop accepts that in some cases the hearers will not understand the
words and teaches then that we must speak gently to the hearts of the
hearers. He realises that in other situations the catechists could be
reticent about expressing themselves openly for fear of offending or
hurting the assembly, and thus advised how they can avoid taking such
risks. Augustine knew such hearers would not respond and remain indifferent,
thus he recalls the teacher to a deeper insight into the mind of his
hearers. There would always be the opportunity to adapt to the kind
of listeners before them, remembering the gender, how many there were
of them, and their social and cultural background. Other difficulties
the catechists could encounter were the distractions to which the hearers
might be subjected. Then it was preferable to allow the catechumens
to seat down to avoid tired people rejecting the words of the Master.
In any case Augustine (6) suggests that when you see tiredness overcoming
the people, you should bring the session to a close.
"Let us speed up our explanation, promising an immediate conclusion
and keeping our word"
3. Baptism - Confirmation - Eucharist
Christian Baptism relates to Christ in the sense that
it is administered by His command and is distinct from other types of
Baptism in use among Hebrews. It did not have a ritual character - because
in that case it could be repeated . Christian baptism instead once it
is received, does not admit repetition, because it was the sign of pardon
of sins and new birth in Christ.
On the basis of literary sources we can reconstruct
the baptismal rite as it developed in antiquity. Normally the catechumen
went, after a long period of preparation, to obtain Baptism from the
Bishop at the Easter Vigil. Having anointed the candidate several times,
renunciation of worldly temptations and exorcisms followed with several
blessings with water. Finally there was triple immersion which involved
the request to accept the Symbol. This was requested by the deacon to
whom the catechumen must respond with the affirmation "Credo". The long
ceremony was concluded with the exchange of the kiss of peace with each
of the community present. However these rites were enriched and extended
in some communities giving rise to slightly different liturgies which
were still essentially the same.
Baptism having been conferred, the catechumens became
at full right members of the Church Community. Now they could be called
neophytes, and as such dressed in white tunics, sign of regeneration
received also the Sacrament of Confirmation administered solely by the
bishop. This consisted of an anointing on the forehead with the Sign
of the Cross using Chrism - a perfumed oil - and the Laying on of Hands.
Only from the Vth century, on the initiative of some Gallican dioceses
did Confirmation take on a separate character and was less and less
often conferred together with Baptism. The Eucharist itself was administered
for the first time at the conclusion of the ceremonies by which the
catechumens were transformed into true faithful. In a sense, the candidates
after having been baptised and confirmed entered the Church for the
first time in their lives to take part in the Mass, sharing in the Eucharistic
Banquet with the entire Christian community.
4. Archaeological evidence: The Baptistery
There is almost total silence in regard to the existence
of baptisteries in the times before religious peace (7). The only exception
is furnished by an example found in Dura Europos in Syria where, within
a private house dated to the beginning of the Third Century, there have
been identified places almost certainly used for Christian worship.
The complex has several rooms arranged around a central open air courtyard
used for eucharistic celebrations and liturgical gatherings. One of
these can be shown to have been a baptistery. In comparison with others,
its dimensions are much reduced, but the walls carry pictorial illustrations
of noteworthy standard. Scenes referring to the spiritual dimension
of Baptism are taken from both Old and New Testaments and cover the
most significant center of the room, which has a shallow basin for the
immersion of catechumens. This was surmounted by a canopy supported
on four columns. The adjoining room was perhaps set aside for the sacrament
of Confirmation. The lack of relevant data for baptismal sites in the
period of the I / III centuries leaves us to suppose that in these times
Baptism was conferred where the natural elements came to the aid as
the need arose. Thus people were baptised near rivers, fountains and
springs or they may have adapted preexisting buildings which could be
transformed into baptisteries such as baths, fountains and swimming
pools.
Only from the IVth century, after the religious peace
obtained by Constantine can we document the birth and development throughout
the Roman Empire of buildings planned and constructed specifically for
the rite of Baptism.
Baptisteries generally arose near the cathedral basilicas
and could be constituted by only one room, or they could use side rooms
whose function cannot be determined with certainty. They seem to have
been for holding the different rites and the many phases which made
up the ceremonies of Baptism.
An example of a well-structured baptismal complex with
different rooms attached and which we can reconstruct with sufficient
certainty is that to be found at Salona in Croatia (vide Tav 1, fig
3-4). In this case, fortunately, we can follow, step by step, the various
stages which carried the catechumens on their spiritual journeys to
the conferring of the sacraments. Those to be baptised, having gathered
in the narthex at the edge of the basilica, passed through a doorway
(A) into a spacious hall called the "catechumenate"(B) where they received
final instructions and were prepared spiritually for their reception
of the sacrament. From here through a portico which existed between
the church and the baptistery entrance, they came into a great waiting
room (C) with benches against the walls, where they awaited the moment
of the ceremony. Then, taking their turn, they passed into a small room
(D), the disrobing room, where they undressed to enter the octagonal
baptistery (E) in which they underwent an exorcism and triple immersion
in the baptismal font which was in the form of a cross (F). Then the
baptised gathered near a small apse where the Bishop's chair (G) was,
so that they might be baptised. Then, robed in white garments, they
left the baptistery along the length of the portico and were admitted
into the basilica (H) to participate in the Eucharist.
In the many other cases of baptisteries discovered
in archaeological investigations, we cannot always reconstruct the suggestive
catechumenal journey with such certainty and at the most we must limit
ourselves to noting the variety of structural types which took on a
certain degree of mystic symbolism.This became more and more obvious
in the mosaic decorations and shapes of the baptismal fonts. They, of
varying depths according to whether they were to be used for immersion
or pouring and sometimes provided with systems of flowing water, could
be square-shaped or rectangular thus recalling the tomb of Christ, the
four corners of the earth, the four Gospels or the tetragram of Jahweh.
Sometimes they were cruciform and carried strong allegories of the death
of the Redeemer alluding to the neophyte's death to sin. The 8-sided
and hexagonal fonts proclaim a language derived from the cosmic mysteries
of the East - the eighth day - that of the General Judgment and Final
Resurrection.
5. Archaeological Evidence: Inscriptions
Gravestones, Greek and Latin, recovered from the catacombs
or cemeteries open to the skies, provide also some references to the
Sacraments, and in a special way to Baptism (8). There are frequent
cases where Christians wished to record on their epitaphs their status
in the womb of the Church. To express the concept of having obtained
pardon from sin through Baptism, Christians of the early centuries had
recourse to short, succinct phrases defining themselves as renatus
(reborn), luce renobatus (renewed in the light), or they used
phrases like gratiam accepit (he or she received the grace) or
more rarely the explicit statement babtizatus a (baptised into).
There are frequent cases where Christians are recorded as having died
a short time before receiving Baptism and thus catechumenus (catechumen)
or candidatus in Christo (candidate to be a Christian) is recorded
on the stones. Thus those Christians who died after having just received
the sacrament were recorded as neophyta (neophyte) or neophotistos
(recently enlightened).
An excellent example of this was the inscription (9)
of a child who died in the middle of the Vth century, of whom is recorded
the date of birth, the date of Easter when he received Baptism, the
Christian name the child took and the date of his death which was on
the following Sunday, Domenica in Albis.
Here lies Paschasius, born with the name Severus, in Eastertide,
Thursday 4th April. . . lived 6 years, received the grace on 21st
April and left his white baptismal vestments in the sepulchre on the
Octave of Easter.
The Sacrament of Confirmation is also mentioned in
epigraphs, but very rarely and generally with a slightly-stereotyped
formula referring to anointing - with chrism (and signed-perhaps consecrated
to the East). A sarcophagus from Spoleto has a neophyte woman, Picentia
Legitima, confirmed by Pope Liberius whose pontificate was from 352-366
(10).
One ext particularly rich in information on conferring
the Sacraments is the epigraph cut on the noble sarcophagus of the couple
Flavius Julius Catervius and Septimia Severina, which was found in Tolentino
(11). In it, apart from references to Baptism and Confirmation, there
is added one to the Sacrament of Matrimony which is couched in poetic
terms full of shining hope in the resurrection.
" The Lord Almighty who with equal merit has joined you in the
sweet bonds of Matrimony looks forever after your sepulchre, O Catervius.
Severina is happy to be united with you forever. May you be raised
together, with the grace of Christ, O you blessed ones, whom Probianus,
the priest of the Lord washed with Baptism and anointed with sacred
chrism."
There are not many christian epigraphs alluding to
the Eucharist but those that are have a great value above all because
they strongly reveal the dogmatic element. In the Basilica of San Lorenzo
fuori le mura near Rome was uncovered an epitaph (12) which affirms
that verus in altari cruor est vinum (the wine on the altar is authentic
blood) showing an explicit allusion to the teaching of Transubstantiation
(Theol) Conversion of whole substance of eucharistic bread and wine
into body and blood respectively of Christ. (The Oxford Dictionary).
Other references to the sacrament of the Eucharist are in some long
and complex sepulchral poems given in Greek. The first comes from Autun
in France. In this text (13) a certain Pettorius who laid out the sepulchre
for his own deceased parents, brings back the palaeochristian christological
symbol of the fish. With a certain poetic turn of phrase, the text is
a yearning eucharistic praise.
"Receive the nourishment sweet as honey from the Saviour of Saints.
When you are hungry, eat the "fish" held in your hands. Nourish me
with this Fish, O Lord my Saviour. I entreat You that my mother may
sleep well, O Light of the dead. And you O father, Ascandius, dearest
to my heart, with my beloved mother and my brothers, you who are in
the peace of the Fish, remember your Pettorius."
As much important is the epigraph of Abercius , bishop
in Phrygia who lived in the second century. Recalling his visit to Rome,
he affirmed that he was assiduous in receiving the Eucharist. In the
text is found the same symbolism of the fish that we saw in the previous
inscription.
"Christ brought me to Rome to contemplate the royal palace. .
.Faith guided me everywhere and whenever I came to the banquet I was
nourished with fish from the fountain, grown pure from the Holy Virgin,
and given to friends that they might always be nourished. We always
have agreeable wine which she offered us mixed with the water together
with bread."
The meaning is clear enough: Wherever he went Abercius
(14), was given the fish for nourishment, the divine flesh offered by
the Church to faithful to nourish them always. The divine banquet consisted
of the eucharistic species, wine mixed with water and bread, the Body
and Blood of Christ.
This final testimony of Abercius concludes our brief
review of the Catechumenate in the Church of the early centuries. It
allows us to take our leave, with a suggestive parallel between the
arrival of Abercius in Rome, sent by Christ and all our journeys as
Christians. Even centuries later we reach the same city in which Abercius
approached with the same loving guidance of the divine Master. The inscription
exhorts us to perseverance in spite of the thousands of pilgrimages
life imposes on us. We are to remain safe in the sacraments which the
community of the Church of Rome, today, as yesterday, administers.
(1) On the organisation of the
catechumenate see particularly B. Capelle, L'introduction du catéchuménate
à Rome à la fin du second siècle in RTAM (Recherses de théologie ancienne
et médiévale) Louvain 5 1933 pp. 129-154; V. Monachino, La cura pastorale
a Milano, Cartagine e Roma nel secolo IV, Roma 1947. A. Turck, Evangélisation
et Catéchèse aux deux premiers siècles, Paris 1962; P. Rentinck, La
cura pastorale in Antioch nel IV secolo Roma 1970; V. Monachino, S.
Ambrogio e la cura pastorale a Milano nel secolo IV, Milano 1973; J.
Danielou - R. Du Charlay, La catechesi nei primi secoli, Torino 1982;
G. Filoramo- S. Roda, Cristianesimo e società antica, Bari 1992. For
the ancient literary sources, it is obviously better to take translations
directly from the original Greek or Latin into English e.g. Ambrose,
The Sacraments, Mysteries, Explanation of the Symbol. Augustine, De
Catechezandis rudibus. Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechesis. Didache, Teaching
of the Twelve Apostles. Gregory of Nyssa, Discourse on Catechetics.
Hippolytus, Apostolic Tradition. Tertullian, Treatise on Baptism.
(2) Augustine, De Catech, 9.
(3) Apostolic Tradition, 16.
(4) John Chrysostom, Catech. I,1.
(6) Augustine, De Catech. ,1.
(5) Augustine, De Catech., 19.
(7) For archaeological evidence in general see P. Testini, Archeologia
cristiana, Bari: 1980; for baptisteries in particular see A. Khatchatrian,
Les baptistères paléochretiens, Paris 1962; B. Gabricevic, Piscine battesimali
cruciformi recentemente in Dalmatia in Akten des VII Internationalen
Kongress für christliche Archdologie, Città Vaticana - Berlin: 1969
pp. 539ff; I Nikolajevic, Les baptistères paléochretiens in Zbornik
radova vizantoloskog Instîtuta 9 1966 pp 223 ff. For Iconography, see
Martimort, L'iconographie des catacombes et la catéchèse antique in
Rivista di Archeologia Cristiana 25 1949 pp. 105-114; G. Belvederi La
catechesi di S. Pietro, Città del Vaticano 1950; L. De Bruyne, L'initiation
chrétienne et ses effets dans l'art paléochretien in SR ( 36 1962 pp.
27-85.
(8) For epigraphic formulae relating to sacraments and to the catechumenate
in particular see Testini, Archeologia cristiana Bari 1980 pp. 416 -
428. See also C. Carlem, Inscrizioni cristiane a Roma. Testimoniaze
di vita cristiana (secoli III-VII) Firenzi 1986 in partircular pp 85-102.
(9) ILCV (Inscriptiones Latinae Christianae Veteres) 154 I
(10) ILCV 965.
(11) ILCV 98b
(12) Nuovo Bullettino di Archeologia Cristiana 1921 p. 106.
(13) See M. Guarducci, Nuove osservazioni sull'iscrizione eucaristica
di Pektorios in Rendiconti della Pontificia Accademia Romana di Archeologia
1947-49 pp. 243ss.
(14) See A. Ferrua, Nuove osservazioni sull' epitaffio di Abercius in
Rivista di Archeologia Cristiana 1943 pp. 279. Also A Ferrua- D. Balboni,
Epitaphium Abercii, Fano 1953.
(The article
is being reprinted, by kind permission of the Author and of the Editor,
from the magazine "Catechisti nella città", Piazza S. Giovanni in Laterano,
6, 00184,Roma,1995,pp.3-11
|